A Call for Restorative Justice: Charlton ‘BB’ Horton’s Second Chance

By Kelly Bailey Simmons

In the heart of West Virginia, a man named Charlton “BB” Horton has spent the last 30 years behind bars, serving a Life Without Mercy sentence since the age of 18. As his court hearing on Monday, Dec. 4, approaches, the community must come together to support BB’s quest for a second chance, questioning the disparities in sentencing, especially for a young Black man convicted during the “tough on crime” era of the early to mid-90s.

West Virginia, like many states, grapples with racial inequalities within its legal system. BB’s story sheds light on the harsh reality faced by individuals caught in the web of a system that often fails to consider the capacity for change. A Life Without Mercy sentence denies the opportunity for redemption and rehabilitation, a judgment that contradicts the experiences of those who know BB intimately.

Despite being labeled as someone “beyond hope” and “beyond redemption,” BB has a community rallying behind him. Letters and video testimonials paint a picture of a kind-hearted, intelligent individual with a contagious smile, a non-violent nature, and exceptional basketball skills. These testimonials, along with a compelling Second Chance Participatory Defense Social Biography video, aim to challenge the narrative that has kept BB confined for three decades.

The irony is stark when considering the financial investment in keeping individuals like BB behind bars. As the Mineral County Commission is granted a significant portion of a $1.2 million Justice Assistance Grant, allocating $39,750, the question arises: is it not more sensible to invest in individuals like BB, who, if given a chance, could contribute positively to programs like the Prevention Resource Officer (PRO) Program?

Join us in rewriting the narrative!
Charlton “BB” Horton’s story is a call for change. On Monday, December 4, as BB’s court hearing approaches, let’s stand united for justice reform. Join the movement by advocating for legislative changes and supporting returning citizens like BB. Be part of the solution—offer resources for education, employment, and more. It’s a simple act that can reshape lives and communities. Join our Facebook group to be part of the conversation. Together, let’s pave the way for second chances and a future rooted in restorative justice.

In advocating for BB’s release, supporters are not only championing his cause but also promoting justice reform measures that make financial and communal sense. Rather than spending thousands to keep him incarcerated, they envision BB as a valuable asset to the community, sharing his lived experiences to mentor and guide young minds away from the path of crime.

Moreover, the health risks faced by individuals in the prison system cannot be ignored. BB, in his demographic and age range, is susceptible to suffering from health problems due to systemic issues within the prison healthcare system. A second chance would not only provide him with the opportunity to reintegrate into society but also access proper healthcare.

This is a call to action for a community tired of a government system defined by judgment and punishment—a punitive and draconian foundation that has shaped narratives and outcomes for far too long. There is an urgent cry for people to stand up for restorative justice, challenging the preconceived notions that have kept BB behind bars for three decades. As the community’s voice rises, let it be heard that everyone deserves a second chance, regardless of the color of their skin or the mistakes of their youth. Let BB’s story be a catalyst for change, inspiring hope, and advocating for justice reform that benefits both individuals and communities throughout West Virginia and beyond.

Here’s a list of people who contributed to the video: