The Attorney General I Thought I Knew

By Elliot G. Hicks
This article was originally published by Charleston Gazette-Mail, a major, independent, award-winning news service based in Charleston.
While our country was changing around us in the lead-up to the midterm elections, one of our federal judges here in Charleston issued a concerning and humiliating ruling against our attorney general.
Attorney General J.B. McCuskey issued subpoenas to environmental groups, West Virginia Rivers Coalition and 350.org, among others, in October. McCuskey wanted documents dating back to 2017 discussing their public statements on climate and energy, and documents showing their internal conversations about climate research. He demanded to know who their allies in their environmental work were. He demanded to know where their money came from, and whether they shared any resources with other environmental groups.
The several environmental groups asked Judge Joseph R. Goodwin, the presiding judge, to invalidate these subpoenas, saying that the subpoenas were an unconstitutional form of intimidation, chilling them from having open dialog with each other on an issue of public interest. Judge Goodwin agreed. Boy, did Judge Goodwin agree.
The judge can’t issue the final ruling on this until everybody has a full chance to present their evidence at a hearing. That hearing has now been scheduled. But the judge did find some evidence in the documents both sides had already filed that let him reach some preliminary conclusions right now.
The environmental groups called McCuskey’s subpoenas an unfocused fishing expedition. Judge Goodwin agreed in part, but said that instead of using a figurative line or net to catch a couple of fish, McCuskey had tried to dynamite the entire lake, hoping to find some shred of evidence that would support his aggressive tactics. Judge Goodwin said it defied common sense that these environmental groups were sued under the West Virginia Consumer Protection Act when they aren’t producing any product for profit to consumers, meaning that the Attorney General had used a statute that couldn’t even apply.
McCuskey was saying that these environmental groups had misled the public about scientific information on climate change. The problem with his allegation is that the scenario the groups had publicized came straight from a federal government publication, the congressionally mandated Fifth National Climate Assessment published in 2023. I think we would all agree that you shouldn’t be subject to an inquisition of subpoenas for republishing public information originally published by your government.
Not only that, but Judge Goodwin noted a social media post by Attorney General McCuskey describing climate advocates as “insane leftist greeno’s” who are “willing to destroy our economy, and harm our citizens in the name of a quasi-religion and adherence to the doctrine of climate insanity.” In today’s world, this is the kind of slander you get for being a citizen active in trying to preserve West Virginia’s great gift of clean water and clean air.
Does anybody think this is the man to protect our environment, our most precious inheritance, when he savages those who actually care and try to help? Goodwin wrote that the environmental groups had “alleged substantial evidence to support their claim” that McCuskey subpoenas “suggest[ ] a retaliatory motive,” against their protected speech, association, and petitioning rights ensured by the First and Fourteenth Amendments, though the court couldn’t reach any conclusion until it heard all of the evidence.
Having been a practicing lawyer for a little over 45 years I’m well acquainted with J.B. McCuskey. I have practiced law in cases with his father, John McCuskey, a very honorable man, a good lawyer, and a one-time appointee to the West Virginia Supreme Court. I knew his mother from serving on a board with her. She was an outstanding woman and community citizen.
When J.B. McCuskey began to make movements toward political office, I was pleased that this very good young man would offer his efforts toward the public good. At that time we had only begun to see the fringe elements of people who would openly and willingly violate our Constitution and principles for the sake of power. I was pleased to predict that he would not be one of those.
But what person who grew up in the United States thinks it’s acceptable to rustle through the private files of public interest organizations to intimidate them from trying to protect the quality of our water and air? What legally trained person would possibly think that they can invade the donation records of a nonprofit organization just because they have a political interest in appeasing opposing fossil fuel processors? I have frequently referenced the movie “Invasion of the Body Snatchers” to describe the times in which we are now living. We see good and gentle people do alarming and nonsensical things to fit in with the cult mentality that has now developed on the right. The J.B. McCuskey of a few years ago would have been horrified to have been called out by a judge like this. I don’t think he would have ever considered doing what he has now done.
Even before they get to the hearing where Judge Goodwin will make final rulings on these subpoenas with all of the evidence before him, this is a humiliating stain on the office of the Attorney General and an abandonment of protection for free speech that we expect from our public officials.
The mid-term election showed that the public is waking up from the drug that has been Trumpism. I dream of the day when some of my acquaintances of long standing will snap out of the stupor in which they now exist and be human again. Apparently, a lot of people around the country have taken the antidote. We are seeing some budding evidence that the great silent majority of Americans want America to be a spring of aspiration again.
Perhaps J.B. McCuskey is young enough to believe that a political climate that exists is the political climate that will always exist. It won’t. And the stench of this era will not simply rinse out. He embraced it, and he’s stuck with it.
It is unfortunate, though, that when the country is snapping back to its senses, West Virginia is likely to be last again. Politicians like J.B. McCuskey are going to be left naked fighting yesterday’s battles utterly without any legal basis, still trying to please a diminishing group of uninformed voters as if it were 2016, when the rest of the country has moved on.
Elliot Hicks is a Charleston lawyer
If you appreciate BBG's work, please support us with a contribution of whatever you can afford.
Support our stories